Here is another mini-research paper completed for my Rank 1! I am very passionate about multicultural education and wanted to share my thoughts with you!
-Lyndsay
THE MERIT OF MULTICULTURAL EDUCATION
Our world changes every day. Schools have become quite a mixture of ethnic, linguistic, cultural, and experiential plurality due to our diversity and surge in immigration. Multicultural education is the answer of how to embrace our nation’s increasing diversity. James A Banks, “the father of multicultural education”, defines multicultural education as “an inclusive concept used to describe a wide variety of school practices, programs, and material designed to help children from diverse groups to experience educational equality” (Banks, 1984, p. 182). Multicultural education is the solution to creating world-ready students.
One of the main benefits of implementing multicultural education would be that our students are able to develop both ethnic and cultural literacy. Students are able to learn about historical backgrounds, cultural characteristics, contributions, languages, significant individuals, critical events, and economic conditions of the various majority and minority ethnic groups. Unfortunately, some, or even many, of these topics are forgotten in texts and lessons (Gay, 1994). Students are entering, and already a part of, a very globalized world. By not allowing them to develop their cultural and ethnic literacy, we would be putting students at a major disadvantage.
By developing cultural and ethnic literacy, students are also gaining skills for life beyond high school. As educators, it is our responsibility to create 21st-century learners; multicultural education does just this. If a student is part of a classroom that focuses on multicultural education, thus avoiding textbooks and lessons that focus predominantly on White/Anglo-Saxon identities, and instead choose to teach using textbooks and materials that discuss a wider range of cultures and historical backgrounds, students will clearly benefit. Students will receive a more well-rounded approach, therefore creating students and workers who are more inclusive, knowledgeable, community-oriented, and compassionate. As a side benefit, students will be much more prepared for living and working in a diverse community (O’Grady, 2000).
A third benefit is that while more opportunities are being created for new types of learning, we are also increasing the number of equal learning opportunities. Multicultural education creates these equal learning opportunities for students, regardless of race and/or ethnic background. By teaching with multiculturalism in mind, diversity is encouraged through the promotion of appreciation and respect for cultural differences. Students will also learn how to recognize social injustices, such as prejudice and/or bias. Through this recognition, students will also be better equipped to combat these social injustices. Multicultural education truly sets a goal of encouraging cooperation and equality while eradicating stereotypes and the bias that comes with negative thinking. Thus, with multicultural education, students will be taught how to develop strong identities based on who they are as people, focusing on abilities, dreams, goals, interests, values, and cultural background, instead of focusing on the color of their skin and the superficial (Derman-Sparks and Ramsey, 2011). Research also shows that multicultural education aides in the improvement of mastery of writing, reading, and mathematical skills, as well as critical thinking, and conflict resolution, all of which are skills that will benefit students beyond their academic career. Additionally, if the education includes the use of ethnic materials, examples, and experiences, as the context for the educational process, educators will be increasing the appeal of instructional tools, heightening practical relevance of skills to be learned, and improving attention to a task. In addition, the combination created by these conditions will lead to task persistence, greater focused efforts, academic achievement, and skill mastery. Clearly, multicultural education will create the citizens we need for a successful future (Gay, 1994).
A common argument against multicultural education is that the implementation will fragment and alienate rapport and communication between ethnic groups. Bennett states (1995), “to dwell on cultural differences is to foster negative prejudices and stereotypes, and that is human nature to view those who are different as inferior” (p. 29). At times, American schools want to make their students “color blind” to try to ascertain equal treatment and justice for their students. The goal of this approach is also that there is a “sameness” of all cultural backgrounds. What is being missed here, is that the goal of multicultural education is not to “color blind” students. As previously stated, multicultural education is “an inclusive concept used to describe a wide variety of school practices, programs, and material designed to help children from diverse groups to experience educational equality” (Banks, 1984, p. 182). Thus, we are creating culturally and ethnically literate students who are sensitive and understanding of others’ backgrounds.
A second argument against multicultural education is that ethnicity may break up nations. Some will say that focusing on multiculturalism and race could lead to divisiveness between races within our country. Proponents of this thought process feel that multicultural education goes against the typical American traditions of integration of cultures into a majority culture, thus rejecting assimilation. Their argument is also that by doing so, we are creating a country of distinct ethnic groups instead of a homogenous “melting pot” (Schlesinger, 1991). Once again, the goal of multicultural education is not to “break up” our students, but rather to create an understanding of one another. What people may forget is that while the United States may be referred to as a melting pot, it can also be called a salad bowl. Regardless of the “meal” that the United States is, it all comes together to create a “wonderful dish”.
Multicultural education is a wonderful solution to creating world-ready, culturally and ethnically literate students. Like any idea in education, there will be some who disagree. But with such wonderful benefits for students, it is clear to see that our students need this type of forward thinking to make them their best selves.
REFERENCES
Banks, J. A. (1984). Multicultural education and its critics: Britain and the United States. In J.A. Banks (Ed.). Race, Culture, and Education: The Selected Works of James A. Banks,182.
Bennett, C. (n.d.). Comprehensive multicultural education: Theory and practice(3rd ed.). MA: Allen & Bacon.
Derman-Sparks, L., & Ramsey, P. (2011). What if all the kids are white?: Anti-bias multicultural education with young children and families. New York: Teachers College Press.
Gay, G. (1994). A synthesis of scholarship in multicultural education: Urban education program. Oak Brook, IL: NCREL.
O’Grady, C. (2000). Integrating service learning and multicultural education in colleges and universities. New York: Routledge.
Schlesinger, A. (1991, July 8). The cult of ethnicity, good and bad. Time, 21.